Hello dear
Welcome To Supremo Pizza
Supremo Pizza, nestled in Midvale, UT, is a hidden gem renowned for its authentic New York-style pizza. Focusing on quality, the pizzeria crafts each pie with a thin, perfectly crisp crust and premium ingredients, including mozzarella imported from Buffalo. Customer favorites like the five cheese and buffalo pizzas showcase bold flavors, while their pepperoni is a crowd-pleaser with crispy edges. Known for fast service and late-night availability, Supremo Pizza also offers garlic knots and wings, elevating the dining experience. With a cozy atmosphere and a commitment to excellence, it’s no wonder this spot has quickly become a local favorite.
About
Supremo Pizza
Welcome to Supremo Pizza, a hidden gem located at 7355 S 900 E #1 in Midvale, Utah. Our recent culinary adventures have led us to discover this charming pizzeria, quickly becoming our go-to destination for authentic New York-style pizza. With a phone number for easy takeout orders, +1 385-461-4909, they're ready to serve you a slice of their delicious offerings at any time.
At Supremo Pizza, the crust is where the magic begins. The thin, crispy base provides the perfect foundation for their expertly crafted pies. Customers rave about the balance of sauce and cheese, with one enthusiast even noting, "Simple like pizza should be!" Indeed, each bite delivers a delightful crunch that wouldn't be out of place on the bustling streets of New York City.
Moving on to the toppings, Supremo offers an impressive variety of options. The plaintive search for perfectly crispy pepperonis has come to an end for many; as one customer stated, their pepperoni pizza is unparalleled in authenticity. Whether you're indulging in the five-cheese delight, the tangy buffalo chicken, or the smoky BBQ chicken, each dish bursts with flavor. However, keep an eye on the buffalo pizza; it packs a punch with a generous amount of sauce that may surprise the unsuspecting palate.
And let’s not overlook the fan-favorite margherita pizza—crafted with rich mozzarella cheese sourced from Buffalo, this pizza exemplifies freshness and quality. Complementing the pizza, the chicken wings are crisp and juicy with just the right touch, and some patrons recommend doubling your order!
Although the prices may lean a bit higher when ordering through their app, the generous 18" pizzas truly offer incredible value. The Hawaiian pizza in particular shines through, featuring thinly sliced pineapples baked to perfection without the usual runny tang. The undercarriage of each pizza is golden, even, and a delight to behold, solidifying Supremo Pizza as a staple for quality dining.
With a clean and inviting atmosphere, this small eatery encourages a casual yet memorable dining experience. Although parking may present a challenge during nearby events, it is worth the effort. Happy hour or late-night cravings are easily satisfied here, as they're open until 2 AM for your midnight pizza fix!
In conclusion, whether you're looking for a late-night slice or a family feast, Supremo Pizza delivers impressive results. Their commitment to quality ingredients and authentic flavors truly sets them apart. This is more than just another pizza place—it's a gathering spot for food lovers longing for that slice of happiness, making it an absolute must-try in the heart of Utah.
Book a table
Make A Reservation
“ This has become our go to pizza place! Nice thin crust and the right amount of sauce/cheese. Simple like pizza should be! Would have got a photo of the entire pie but my family got to it before I could! ”
“ We have been on the search for the perfect thin crust pizza with those crispy little pepperonis, (you know the ones), and our search has come to an end! Supremo serves up amazing New York-style pizza. Honestly the most authentic we’ve found in Utah. We’ve tried the pepperoni, five cheese (personal fave), buffalo, and BBQ chicken — all were delicious. The flavors are spot on, though the buffalo pizza had a bit more sauce than we expected. We took home the leftovers and threw it in the air fryer the next day and it was even better the second round. Definitely a go-to spot for quality pizza! Food: 10/10 Service: Great Atmosphere: Small, clean space. Parking can be a bit tricky while events are going on next door. Value: Definitely worth driving up to for a late night slice. Pizza always comes out HOT and you can conveniently order ahead on their app. ”
“ I‘be ordered twice from here and liked both pies. I love having this pizzeria in the neighborhood, they do NY style right. It’s a touch pricey, especially when including fees just for ordering with their app, which is a bummer. They do offer rewards. Also the garlic knots should be 0.50/ea., an order of 6 is 8.00... they’re just your basic average garlic knot. I assumed they were either very large or exceptional, neither. ”
“ Unlike any pizza I've ever had. The food here is fresh!! The ingredients are all high quality. We ordered the margherita pizza and wings with sauce on the side. This pizza was made with mozzarella cheese from Buffalo, instead of cow! It was so rich and delicious. The chicken wings tasted so healthy and weren't greasy at all. They were super crispy, juicy and really good size! I recommend ordering 2 orders of the wings. Such a gem of a restaurant and open for delivery until 2am!!!! ”
“ In honor of Bitcoin Pizza Day, I decided to pick up a couple pizzas—and what a delightful surprise it turned out to be. Their menu offers unbeatable value. The prices were incredibly reasonable, especially considering the generous size of the 18" pizzas. The Hawaiian pizza was a standout. The pineapple was sliced thinly, avoiding the usual watery chunks, and baked to perfection. The classic cheese pizza was equally impressive. The crust was light with a slight crisp, and the undercarriage was pure perfection—golden and evenly browned. Supremo Pizza is a bit of a hidden gem—a small, unassuming spot with minimal signage. Despite its modest appearance, the quality of the food speaks volumes. It’s a must-try for anyone in the area looking for authentic, flavorful pizza. Happy Bitcoin Pizza Day! ”
“ Their dough is thin and crispy. Good flavor and friendly staff. There's 2 tables and most people do a takeout. A lot of options available with desserts as well. If the base sauce is the same, then you can do a half-half. The size of the pizza is available in 14" and 18". If you do a dine-in, it takes about 15-20 min for the pizza to be ready. ”
“ Best pizza in Salt Lake County. Great crust. Very flavorful. Garlic knots are fantastic. Download their app and there’s usually a promotion to save some money. ”
“ Great pizza! Thin crust, not floppy, quality toppings. Not from here but would definitely make this my regular spot. ”